Sony PSPs better in the classroom than laptops?
In January I speculated that Apple’s iPhone would soon be seen in classrooms. That post drew such a strong response that I was prompted to go looking for better alternatives that are available now. I think I’ve found one in the Sony PSP, and I am sufficiently convinced that I have approached Sony (via their educational distributor ConnectED) to make them available to Chalkface customers.
The title of the post was deliberately provocative (of course!); it might be better to say that a couple of class sets of PSPs would very nicely augment your current computer suites. Here is now they measure up:
How PSPs are better than laptops
- Much, much cheaper. You can put online, multimedia education into the hands of at least five children for every one with a laptop.
- Wi-fi enabled out of the box. No expensive re-cabling of the school.
- Parental-purchase friendly. Not just because of the low price, either. Students see PSPs as technology designed for them, and will actively campaign for them on your behalf.
- More portable. Whether you are shunting them round the school, or students are taking them home to do homework on, the logistics suddenly get a lot easier.
Great for multimedia especially as the education bundle comes with still/video camera as standard.
- Small and discreet enough not to interfere with classroom practice.
How PSPs are worse than laptops
- No built-in keyboard. The on-screen text entry is rubbish, frankly (Tengo could be very nicely adapted to PSP, and should be), but the PSP will work with an external keyboard.
- Small screen. It’s 480×272 pixels, compared to 800×600 for a typical laptop. Browsing complex websites involves a fair bit of scrolling; simpler websites like Yacapaca are fine.
- No Microsoft applications. If what you are teaching is spreadsheets, a PSP won’t be much good.
Obviously this is an analysis coloured by my view that educational content should be delivered via the web, and that delivery should not get in the way of teachers continuing to teach. The PSP won’t dominate your classroom the way laptops would, but at the same time you only have to look at the way students drive their social lives through TXT and MMS on their phones, to realise the power of small devices matched to nimble fingers.
If you are intrigued by the idea and want to research other teachers’ opinions, here are a few I have gathered together:
- Handheld Learning: Very well-informed discussion on this specialist message board.
- Changing the Game: Bucks LEA advisor Ian Usher’s blog. This was the post that first turned me on to the potential of the PSP – thanks Ian!
- HECC: Wiki page of PSP-related resources, including some very good stuff on RSS feeds.
We are going to have a very small number of demo units available on sale or return soon; let me know if you would like to get on the list for one. Priority will go to regular blog readers and existing Chalkface customers. Product details here.